Retail Theft Defense
Defense against retail theft and shoplifting charges, with a focus on evidence review and record protection.
Defense against retail theft and shoplifting charges, with a focus on evidence review and record protection.
The value that separates a misdemeanor from a felony theft charge is set by each state and ranges from a few hundred dollars to several thousand, depending on where you were charged. Separately from the statute, charging policy has shifted: in several jurisdictions, prosecutors who until recently declined or reduced low-value retail theft cases are now charging them at every level. That is a significant shift. People who assume a retail theft charge will simply go away are working from an assumption that no longer holds.
Most jail and prison sentences for retail theft involve high values, aggravating circumstances, or multiple prior offenses. Jail on a first offense is uncommon. That said, prosecutors in many jurisdictions are now pursuing these charges rather than dismissing them, so the case itself is real and needs to be handled, and what you do in the coming weeks affects how it ends.
Dismissal rests with the prosecutor, and in many jurisdictions it is far less routine than it was a few years ago. There is a step that matters specifically in these cases: reviewing the evidence, including store surveillance footage, loss prevention reports, and witness statements, to determine whether you should have been charged at all. Where the charge does hold, the focus shifts to negotiating with the prosecutor to keep a theft conviction off your record. Depending on the jurisdiction, a diversion or deferred prosecution program may also be available: complete a requirement such as a class, community service, or restitution, and the prosecutor dismisses the charge.
This is usually the consequence that matters most. A theft conviction is treated as an offense of dishonesty, which affects future employment and professional licensing, and it can carry weight in custody and immigration matters. Much of the work in a retail theft case is directed at this: reviewing whether the charge was properly brought, and where it was, negotiating to keep it off your record.
It depends on the value involved, your record, and the state. Among the states where we practice, the felony threshold is $300 in Illinois, $750 in Florida, $950 in California, $1,000 in New York, and $2,500 in Texas, and in several of these states prior theft convictions can raise a low-value charge to a felony. These figures change from time to time, so confirm the current rule for your state. Either way, many prosecutors are now pursuing retail theft at all levels rather than routinely dismissing it, so a misdemeanor charge still calls for a serious response.
That is the main focus of the work. It starts with reviewing the evidence to determine whether the charge should have been brought at all. Where it does hold, the next step is negotiating with the prosecutor for a diversion program, a reduced charge, or another resolution that keeps a theft conviction off your record. No outcome can be guaranteed, but this is where early work makes the most difference.
Contact us to discuss your case and protect your rights confidentially.