Debt & Collection Defense
Defending against collection lawsuits, disputing judgments, and protecting you from unlawful collection practices.
Defending against collection lawsuits, disputing judgments, and protecting you from unlawful collection practices.
Debt is stressful enough without aggressive or unlawful collection tactics. If you are being pursued by creditors or collection agencies, or you are facing a collection lawsuit, you have legal rights and defenses. Federal and state collection laws strictly regulate what third-party debt collectors can do: they cannot harass you, cannot collect more than you owe, and cannot report false information to credit bureaus. Suing or threatening to sue on a debt that is past the statute of limitations is generally treated as a deceptive practice. Some states extend similar rules to original creditors. If a collector violates these laws, you may be able to sue for damages. Understanding your rights and asserting them can stop collection harassment, defeat a weak lawsuit, or lead to a negotiated settlement. An experienced debt defense attorney can help you navigate collection disputes and protect your financial future.
Debt comes in many forms. Secured debt is backed by collateral - a mortgage is secured by your home, an auto loan by your car. If you default on secured debt, the lender can seize the collateral. Unsecured debt has no collateral - credit card debt, medical bills, personal loans, payday loans. Creditors generally must obtain a court judgment before they can garnish wages or levy bank accounts to collect unsecured debt.
When you fall behind on debt, the original creditor may try to collect. If you do not pay, the creditor may hire, or sell the debt to, a debt collection agency, a company that is hired to collect old debts or that purchases them outright. Debt collectors are third parties rather than the original creditor. They are regulated by the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), which does not apply to most original creditors, though many states regulate creditors as well.
Creditors and collectors often report accounts to credit bureaus, which create credit reports used to determine whether you get loans, what interest rate you pay, and sometimes whether you get hired or housing. Inaccurate reporting can damage your credit for years.
Understanding the source of collection efforts and what tactics are legal helps you know when to stand firm and when to negotiate.
The federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) regulates how debt collectors can pursue debts. The law prohibits abusive, unfair, or deceptive practices. Collectors cannot harass you through repeated calls (calling before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. is generally prohibited unless you agree), cannot call you at work if they know your employer prohibits such calls, cannot contact your family members or employer to demand payment, cannot make threats or use profanity, and cannot misrepresent themselves or the debt.
If you send a written request to stop contact (called a cease and desist letter), debt collectors must generally stop contacting you. They may contact you again only to confirm that they are ending collection efforts or to notify you that they intend to take a specific action, such as filing a lawsuit.
Within five days of first contact, a collector must send you a written validation notice stating the amount owed, the creditor's name, and your right to dispute. If you dispute the debt in writing within 30 days, the collector must stop collection efforts and verify the debt before resuming. Many consumers use this right to require collectors to show that the debt is legitimate.
Many states have additional protections beyond federal law. If a collector violates these laws, you may be able to sue for damages and statutory penalties.
Many debt collectors violate the law through harassment and abuse. Common illegal practices include:
Repeated calling: Calling you multiple times per day, calling repeatedly after you ask them to stop, or calling before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m.
Threats: Threatening to sue, seize property, garnish wages, or have you arrested. Threatening to sue is generally unlawful unless the collector actually intends to sue and has the legal right to do so; threatening suit on a debt that is past the statute of limitations is generally treated as deceptive.
Misrepresentation: Claiming to be an attorney or government representative, claiming you owe more than you do, or threatening illegal consequences like arrest for owing a private debt. These tactics may constitute fraud or false collection claims.
Third-party contact: Calling your family members, employer, or coworkers to demand payment (a collector may generally contact a third party only to confirm your location, and may not reveal that you owe a debt).
If a collector violates these laws, document everything: save voicemails, write down the dates and times of calls, keep letters, and note what was said. Then contact an attorney. A consumer may sue a debt collector for statutory damages (capped at $1,000 per lawsuit under federal law, with some state laws, such as California's Rosenthal Act, providing additional amounts), plus actual damages and attorney fees.
If a creditor or debt collector sues you, you may have multiple defenses. One of the strongest is the statute of limitations. The deadline varies by state and by whether the agreement was written or oral. In the states where we have offices, the period for a written contract ranges from four years (California and Texas) to five (Florida), six (New York) and ten (Illinois); oral agreements often carry shorter periods. If the deadline has passed, you can ask the court to dismiss the case. An old debt does not disappear, but the creditor generally loses the legal right to sue on it. Rules change and the facts matter, so the deadline should be confirmed for your situation.
Other defenses include: you already paid the debt (provide evidence - cancelled checks, proof of payment), mistaken identity (the debt belongs to someone else with a similar name), the creditor cannot prove the debt is valid (demand proof - account statements, contracts, chain of title if the debt was sold), the debt was discharged in bankruptcy, or the creditor violated your rights (they may owe you damages that offset the debt).
Many collection lawsuits are weak because the collector cannot produce proper documentation. If you are sued, do not ignore it: respond by the deadline stated in the summons (often between 14 and 30 days, depending on the state and the court) and raise your defenses.
An attorney can help you evaluate your defenses and decide whether to fight the case or negotiate a settlement.
Creditors and debt collectors report to credit bureaus and must report accurately. Common credit-reporting problems include: reporting a debt you already paid, reporting a debt belonging to someone else, reporting the wrong balance, failing to update an account that was discharged in bankruptcy, or continuing to report a delinquent account beyond the reporting period allowed by the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), which is generally seven years from the original delinquency. The FCRA reporting period is separate from the statute of limitations for suing on the debt: an old debt can lawfully remain on your report even if the creditor can no longer sue on it.
If your credit report contains inaccurate information, the first step is usually to dispute it in writing with the credit bureau (you may also dispute directly with the creditor or collector that supplied the information). Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, the bureau must generally investigate within 30 days, and the creditor or collector that supplied the information must reasonably reinvestigate and correct or delete information it cannot verify. If the error is not corrected after you dispute it, you may be able to sue the bureau and, in many cases, the creditor or collector. The FCRA allows recovery of actual damages and attorney fees for negligent violations and, for willful violations, statutory and punitive damages as well.
Getting inaccurate information off your credit report is critical because it affects your credit score, which affects your ability to borrow, what interest rates you pay, and sometimes whether you can get housing or employment.
Check your credit reports regularly (you get free reports at annualcreditreport.com). If you find errors, dispute them immediately and contact an attorney if the errors persist.
If a creditor or collector files a lawsuit, you will receive a summons and complaint. You have a limited time to respond, set by the summons (often between 14 and 30 days, depending on the state and the court). Do not ignore it: if you do not respond, the creditor can obtain a default judgment and, depending on your state's exemption laws, garnish wages or levy bank accounts.
File a written answer or motion raising your defenses. Require the creditor to prove the debt: it must produce account statements, the contract, and a proper chain of title if the debt was sold. Many collection cases are dismissed because the creditor cannot meet that burden.
Even if a judgment is entered against you, you may be able to appeal, negotiate a payment plan, or claim exemptions that protect certain income and property. State law limits wage garnishment and bank levies in different ways: Texas, for example, generally prohibits wage garnishment for ordinary consumer debts, and every state exempts some income and property from collection. Understanding your state's law is critical.
An attorney can help you respond to the lawsuit, raise defenses, and negotiate the best possible outcome.
If you are facing collection calls, a collection lawsuit, or inaccurate credit reporting, you have rights and defenses. Debt collectors sometimes violate the law through harassment, false threats, and misrepresentation. We defend consumers against collection lawsuits, demand validation of debts, send cease-and-desist letters, challenge inaccurate credit reports, and pursue claims against collectors for violations. Many collection defenses are inexpensive to raise; asserting them can stop collection efforts or defeat the lawsuit. Contact us for a confidential consultation.
Contact us to discuss your debt or collection defense confidentially.