Fraud & Misrepresentation
Civil fraud, misrepresentation, and claims where you were deceived or financially harmed by another party.
Civil fraud, misrepresentation, and claims where you were deceived or financially harmed by another party.
Fraud occurs when someone deliberately deceives you to induce you to enter into a transaction and profits from your reliance on the false statement. Whether you were misled in a business deal, deceived in a real estate transaction, or defrauded in an investment scheme, you may have a civil claim for damages. Civil fraud is different from criminal fraud: in civil court, you sue for money damages rather than seeking criminal prosecution. If you have been deceived and financially harmed, an attorney can help you evaluate your claim, pursue recovery, and hold the wrongdoer accountable.
Criminal fraud is prosecuted by the government to punish the defendant and protect the public. If convicted, the defendant may face fines or imprisonment. Civil fraud is a lawsuit you file to recover money damages for your losses. You are suing the wrongdoer for compensation, not asking the government to punish them.
You can pursue a civil fraud claim even if the defendant was never criminally prosecuted, and even if the defendant was acquitted of criminal charges. Civil cases use a lower burden of proof than criminal cases, which require proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The civil standard for fraud varies by state. Some states, including New York and Illinois, require fraud to be proven by "clear and convincing evidence", a standard higher than the ordinary civil "preponderance of the evidence" standard but still lower than the criminal one. Others, including Florida, California and Texas, generally apply the preponderance standard to fraud claims, although a higher standard may apply before punitive damages can be awarded. In every case, a civil fraud claim can succeed even where prosecutors could not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
You do not need to wait for criminal prosecution to pursue a civil claim. In fact, you should pursue civil recovery promptly, because statutes of limitations limit how long you have to sue.
In a civil fraud case, you may recover compensatory damages (the money you lost) and, in cases of egregious conduct, punitive damages (designed to punish the wrongdoer and deter future misconduct). Attorney fees and court costs are generally recoverable only where a contract or a statute (such as a state consumer-fraud law) provides for them.
To establish a civil fraud claim, a plaintiff must generally prove: (1) the defendant made a false statement or omitted material facts that the defendant had a duty to disclose, (2) the defendant knew the statement was false or made it with reckless disregard for its truth, (3) the defendant intended for you to rely on the false statement, (4) you reasonably relied on the statement in making your decision, and (5) you suffered damages as a result of that reliance. The precise formulation varies by state.
Each element is important. If the defendant made a false statement but did not know it was false and had no reason to know, that is not fraud; it is innocent misrepresentation, and remedies are limited. If you should have known the statement was false (for example, a used car salesman tells you a car with 200,000 miles and visible rust "runs like new"), your reliance may not be reasonable, and your claim may fail. If you suffered no damages, you cannot recover even if fraud occurred.
Proving fraud requires evidence: emails, text messages, written statements, testimony from witnesses, expert opinions on valuation or causation, and documentation of your losses. Fraudsters often cover their tracks, but evidence of their knowledge (internal emails admitting problems, prior similar schemes, warnings they ignored) can be critical to proving intent.
The law generally recognizes three types of misrepresentation, each with different remedies:
Innocent misrepresentation occurs when someone makes a false statement but genuinely believes it is true and has no reason to know better. For example, a seller tells a buyer "this house has never flooded," but unknowingly, the basement flooded years ago before the current owner bought it. Innocent misrepresentation generally supports rescission of the transaction (unwinding it and returning what each side gave) but usually not additional damages.
Negligent misrepresentation occurs when someone makes a false statement without reasonable investigation or verification. A real estate agent tells a buyer "there are no foundation problems," but the agent never had the foundation inspected. Negligent misrepresentation can support rescission and, in many states, recovery of your actual out-of-pocket losses; it generally does not support punitive damages.
Fraudulent misrepresentation (or intentional fraud) occurs when someone makes a false statement knowing it is false, or makes it recklessly without regard for whether it is true, intending that you rely on it. Intentional fraud can support rescission, compensatory damages for your losses, and, in appropriate cases, punitive damages.
The distinction matters because remedies differ. Innocent misrepresentation generally supports rescission; negligent misrepresentation can add recovery of actual out-of-pocket losses; and only intentional fraud supports the full range of damages, including, in appropriate cases, punitive damages.
Affirmative fraud occurs when someone makes an affirmatively false statement. Concealment and non-disclosure occur when someone hides or fails to reveal material facts that they have a duty to disclose.
Not all silence is fraud. In ordinary commercial transactions, "caveat emptor" (buyer beware) applies: you are expected to investigate. A seller is not obligated to volunteer every negative fact. However, in many contexts, someone who knows material facts has a duty to disclose them: in most states a residential real estate seller must disclose known defects, a party to a business sale may have disclosure duties under the purchase agreement or securities laws, and an insurance applicant must answer questions truthfully.
Fraud can occur through concealment if someone actively hides information (painting over mold, removing inspection reports, failing to disclose known environmental contamination) or through non-disclosure when someone has a legal duty to disclose and deliberately fails to do so.
Whether non-disclosure constitutes fraud depends on the relationship between the parties and applicable law. In residential real estate, sellers in most states have statutory disclosure duties. In business sales, disclosure duties are often spelled out in the purchase agreement. Understanding your rights requires knowing the law of your state and the specific context of your transaction.
Fraud occurs across many contexts. In real estate transactions, sellers may conceal defects: known foundation problems, water damage, previous floods, structural issues, or hazardous materials. In business sales, sellers may hide liabilities, exaggerate profits, or fail to disclose pending lawsuits or environmental violations. In investment schemes, fraudsters promise returns that are too good to be true, hide risks, or simply steal investor money.
Consumer fraud includes false advertising (overstating product benefits), bait-and-switch schemes, hidden fees, and pressure to buy before you understand what you are getting. In insurance contexts, fraud includes misrepresentation to insurers or concealment of material facts. Relationship fraud occurs when someone builds trust specifically to defraud you: romantic scams, "advance fee" schemes, and fake job offers all fall into this category.
In each context, the key questions are: did the defendant make a false statement or conceal material facts, did the defendant know it was false or have reason to know, and did you suffer damages as a result? Fraud can also arise from personal financial disputes involving loans, partnerships, or family money.
If you have been defrauded, document everything immediately: save all communications, write down what you were told and when, gather evidence of your damages, and contact an attorney promptly. Fraud claims have statutes of limitations, so time is critical.
If you prove fraud, you may pursue several remedies. Rescission means canceling the transaction and restoring the parties to their prior positions: the court orders the defendant to return what you paid, and you return what you received. Rescission is often the remedy for fraud in real estate or other property transactions.
Compensatory damages are the money you lost as a result of the fraud. If you bought a business relying on false profit statements and it turns out to be worthless, you may be able to recover the purchase price and any money you invested. If you bought a house whose seller concealed foundation damage and you had to pay for repairs, you may recover the repair costs.
Punitive damages are additional damages designed to punish and deter. Courts may award them when the defendant's conduct was especially egregious: deliberately deceptive, reckless, or malicious. Several states cap punitive damages or require a heightened standard of proof before they can be awarded, so their availability depends on state law and the facts of the case.
Attorney fees and court costs are recoverable in some fraud cases, generally where a contract or a statute (such as a state consumer-fraud law) provides for them. We handle these matters on a contingency-fee basis: attorney fees are paid only from a recovery. Court costs and case expenses may apply and are discussed before representation begins.
You cannot wait indefinitely to sue for fraud. Every state has a statute of limitations, a deadline for filing suit. Most states apply a "discovery rule" to fraud, so the clock starts when you discovered, or reasonably should have discovered, the deception rather than when the fraud occurred. The length of the period, and whether an outside cap applies regardless of discovery, varies by state. In the states where we have offices: New York allows six years from the fraud or two years from discovery, whichever is later; Illinois allows five years, with a discovery rule; Florida allows four years from discovery, subject to an outside limit of twelve years from the fraud; California allows three years from discovery; and Texas allows four years, with a discovery rule.
For example, if a seller conceals foundation damage and you do not discover it until two years after purchase (during an inspection for a refinance), the limitations period in most states starts to run from the date of discovery rather than the date of sale. How much time remains depends on your state's period, any outside cap, and when a court concludes you reasonably should have discovered the problem. Rules change and the facts matter, so deadlines should be confirmed with an attorney promptly.
If you suspect you have been defrauded, do not delay. Contact an attorney promptly to understand your rights and deadlines. Missing the statute of limitations generally bars the claim, regardless of its merits.
If you have been deceived in a transaction and suffered a financial loss, you may have a fraud claim. Whether you were misled in a real estate deal, a business transaction, an investment, or a consumer purchase, an attorney can help you understand your options and pursue recovery. We handle these matters on a contingency-fee basis: attorney fees are paid only from a recovery. Court costs and case expenses may apply and are discussed before representation begins. Do not wait; statutes of limitations limit how long you have to sue. Contact us for a confidential consultation.
Contact us to discuss your fraud or misrepresentation claim confidentially.